Saturday, December 21, 2013

Hindu priests condemn Ayodhya incident, appeal for peace - By Abu Zafar - www.indiatomorrow.net

http://www.indiatomorrow.net/eng/one-year-of-nirbhaya-rape-case-why-crimes-still-continue




Hindu priests condemn Ayodhya incident, appeal for peace

21 Dec 2013 05:12 PM, IST


Hindu priests condemn Ayodhya incident, appeal for peace

By Abu Zafar, India Tomorrow,
New Delhi/Ayodhya, 21 Dec 2013: As news spread about attack on a Muslim shrine and murder of a 22-year-old undergraduate student in Uttar Pradesh’s town Ayodhya last evening, several Hindu saints of the ancient religious town have come out condemning the incident and appealing to both communities to maintain peace and calm.
Acharya Satyendra Das, chief priest of makeshift Ram Janmabhoomi temple, Ayodhya termed the incident very sad.
“It is a very sad incident. I condemn it,” Satyendra Das told India Tomorrow.
He said that Hindus and Muslims live here peacefully and the shrine is respectable for both communities.
“Police is investigating the matter and I hope the guilty persons will be caught soon,” he added
About six unidentified men on Friday evening entered Jinnati Mosque and brutally killed moazzin (azan caller) who was a 22-year-old undergraduate student. Then the attackers barged into an ancient Muslim shrine housing a large grave which is popularly believed to be of Prophet Shis, and damaged the boundary wall of the grave. The slain youth Mohammad Danish hailed from Rohtas district of Bihar. He was the first year student of Bachelor of Science (Agriculture) at Shree Paramhans Shikshan Prashikshan PG College in Ayodhya.
Some Hindu priests see it as a political conspiracy for electoral gains.
Condemning the incident, Mahant Udar Das, president of Kabir Math in Ayodhya said: “It is a very unfortunate incident, I strongly condemn it. It may be a conspiracy to gain political mileage. I appeal to both Hindu and Muslim brothers to maintain calm and peace.”
Naga Damodar Das, priest of Hanumangarhi, said: “I don’t like violence any way. People are doing such things for political gain. Even whatever happened in 1992 was very sad and unfortunate. People from both communities must treat it gently.”
Talking to India Tomorrow earlier in the day, Faizabad Superintendent of Police Ram Sewak Gautam had said some people have been taken into custody for questioning. “We have detained some people for questioning in regard with the murder and attack on the shrine,” SP said.

All India Muslim Majlis-e Mushawarat Markazi Majlis (Central Committee) meeting - Press Statement


ALL INDIA MUSLIM MAJLIS-E-MUSHAWARAT
[Umbrella body of the Indian Muslim organisations]
D-250, Abul Fazal Enclave, Jamia Nagar
New Delhi-110025 India

All India Muslim Majlis-e Mushawarat
Markazi Majlis (Central Committee) meeting
21 December, 2013

PRESS STATEMENT
New Delhi, 21 December, 2013: The Markazi Majlis (Central Committee) of the All India Muslim Majlis-e Mushawarat (AIMMM), umbrella body of Indian Muslim organisations and eminet personalities, held its second meeting of the year here today at the central office. The meeting, the first after the reunification of the two factions of Mushawarat last October, was chaired by the AIMMM National President Dr Zafarul-Islam Khan and attended by the following members: Maulana Syed Jalaluddin Umari, Janab Mohammad Jafar (Vice President), Syed Shahabuddin,  Maulana Junaid Ahmad Banarasi, Dr. Anwarul Islam,  Janab Nusrat Ali, Janab Abdur Rahman Kondoo, Dr. Javed Jamil, Dr Jawed Ahmad, Prof. Mateen Ahmad Siddiqui, Mufti Ataur Rahman Qasmi, Janab Mujtaba Farooq, Janab Amanullah Khan, Janab Masoom Moradabadi, Janab Abdul Khaliq, Janab Manzoor Ahmad, IPS (Retd.), Janab Shahid Sharif Shaikh  and Janab Akhtar Husain Akhtar.
he meeting offered condolences to the millat and families of prominent leaders of the community who passed away recently and prayed for their souls, especially to MUFTI MUHAMMAD ASHFAQUE HUSAIN NAEEMI of Rajasthan, MUSHTAQUE MADNI, editor of Usool, Pune, Dr WAZARAT RASOOL KHAN, KHWAJA MUZAFFAR HUSAIN RIZVI, SYED HASNAIN MIAN NAZMI MARAHRAVI, sajjadanashin of Khanqah Barkatiya Marahra, MAULANA IBRAHIM MIAN SAHEB of South Africa, a khalifa of Shaikhul Hadees Maulana Zakarya, PROF NOORUL ISLAM of Aligarh, and SHEIKH HAFIZ ZUBER ALIZAI Mau Nath Bhanjan.
The meeting discussed organisational, milli, national and international issues and passed the following RESOLUTIONS: 
Muzaffarnagar riots
The one-sided anti-Muslim violence, which erupted in the rural areas of Muzaffarnagar, Shamli and Baghpat districts of western Uttar Pradesh last September, is a blot on the face of India in general and the Samajwadi party ruling the state in particular. The state government alongwith its local machinery failed to anticipate or even to take action as soon as the riots started and has since continued in denial of the enormity of the event and its tragic fallout for close to one lakh Muslims who had to flee their villages and take refuge in over 30 refugee camps in Shamli and Muzaffarnagar districts. Many have since returned to their villages or settled elsewhere while still there are around 15,000 people living in some two dozen camps in sub-human conditions, surviving in plastic tents while their children are not accepted by local schools and colleges and both Jats and local administration are pressurising them to withdraw FIRs and drop legal cases against the criminals who killed, burnt alive, raped and uprooted a large population within a span of two days on 7-8 September this year. 
AIMMM appeals to the state and Central governments to work in seriousness for the long-term rehabilitation of these refugees who do not wish to return to their villages. Their children must be admitted to local schools and colleges, their FIRs and legal cases should be seriously pursued to punish the criminals and they should be provided with free land to settle as they are camping at present on forest and private lands which they will have to vacate sooner or later.
AIMMM lauds the services of the local madrasas and mosques which sprang to the help of the victims and appreciates the services of the civil society, especially Muslim organisations like Jamaat-e Islami Hind, Jamiat Ulama-e Hind, Zakat Foundation and Charity Alliance etc which have offered timely help and are busy in the difficult work of the refugees’ rehabilitation. AIMMM appreciates the efforts of Jamaat-e Islami Hind to bring Jats and Muslims of the riot-hit area around Muzaffarnagar closer in a bid to allow the return of the uprooted to their villages with honour and dignity.
Politics of Communal riots
Over two hundred communal riots have been recorded within a few months before the recent elections in five states. It is now clear that communal riots are engineered by certain, especially Sangh Parivar, forces while other political and administrative forces allow this to happen. It is the responsibility of the civil society and media to come forward to expose this nexus which is a blot on the face of our democracy. There is a movement now against corruption but the equally dangerous poison of communalism continues to be ignored and tolerated.
Communal Violence (Prevention) Bill
The AIMMM notes with regret that both Congress and BJP conspired to prevent the passage of the Communal Violence (Prevention) Bill in the current session of Parliament while both cooperated to get the watered-down Lokpal bill passed. The Communal violence bill too has been watered-down but even in its present form it will make the local administration accountable, which will be an important step to check riots. AIMMM believes that both BJP and Congress have an interest to let things continue as they are as both benefit from the outcome of communal riots and both are united to prevent the Muslim community from enjoying peace and communal harmony needed for progress and prosperity.
Islamic finance
Islamic, or ethical, finance and banking has become an accepted mode of alternative finance in many parts of the world. Of late, UK has decided to become the hub of Islamic finance which offers an alternative to the interest-based exploitative commercial lending. Despite various assurances by Indian politicians including Prime Minster Manmohan Singh and recommendations of the Committee on Financial Sector Reforms of the Planning Commission (2008), whose chairman is now the governor of RBI, the Indian government continues to drag its feet in this field. It is time India took a brave step to allow this form of financial activity to break the vicious circle of private and corporate money-lenders and offer a large segment of the Indian population a chance to invest and participate in the financial sector with clear conscience.
Article 370
BJP’s prime-ministerial candidate has suggested  a debate over Article 370 of the Indian Constitution which binds Jammu & Kashmir with India. AIMMM reiterates that no attempt should be made to change the constitutional guarantees given to J&K. Any attempt to do so will only antagonise a large section of J&K people, both Muslims and Hindus, which in turn will reopen the question of the accession of the state to the Indian Union. Such a mayhem suits BJP since it marvels in fishing in muddy waters, but the whole country will suffer from the repercussions of such an attempt to tamper with Article 370 which binds J&K with India.

Homosexuality -- Article 377
The AIMMM welcomes the decision of the Supreme Court of India to overturn the 2009 Delhi High Court decision and order to continue criminalisation of unnatural sexual relations under Article 377. The AIMMM warns certain elements in Indian civil society and political parties to desist from removing or altering Article 377 as it will be a betrayal to the customs, traditions and beliefs of an overwhelming majority of Indians and rejection of the teachings of all religions and creeds prevailing in India.
Village Defence Committees
Government-sponsored and protected VDCs in J&K, especially in Chenab valley, are terrorising the local population. Out of 12,709 armed members of the VDCs in Chenab valley alone, 11,745 are Hindus which does not reflect the ground reality. This illegal militia openly misuses its officially-provided arms and this was very clear during the Eidul Fitr riots in Kishtwar last August. For communal peace and tranquility, this illegal entity should be disbanded forthwith and the state should desist from relegating the role of police and security agencies to unaccountable entities.
Persian and Arabic
AIMMM notes with pain and dismay that the UPSC has dropped Arabic and Persian languages from the list of permitted languages for public service exams while almost dead or limited-use languages are kept on the list. Persian is very important for our country as it was the official language for almost seven centuries and all our official and private records of the pre-1857 period are in Persian. Arabic, on the other hand, is the official language of 23 countries in the Middle East and North Africa with which we have strong commercial and cultural relations. Any dilution of the importance of these two languages will only harm our own country.
Bangladesh
AIMMM condemns the judicial murder of Abdul Qadir Molla by the government of Hasina Wajed in Bangladesh using a controversial verdict issued by a discredited tribunal. The hasty execution of a prominent leader of Jamaate-Islami Bangladesh is a scandal and crime committed by an unpopular government which is about to be overthrown by the people of Bangladesh in the forthcoming general elections. The present government by its hurried execution of a controversial order by a politicised tribunal is only seeking to weaken opposition forces. AIMMM believes that it was totally unfair to revive closed cases after four decades defying the decision of the first President of Bangladesh. AIMMM appeals to international human rights organisations to take the Bangladesh government and its discredited tribunal to the International Court of Justice as sanity and good counsel have failed to bring the present rulers of Bangladesh to their senses.
Angola
AIMMM is deeply concerned about the treatment of Muslims in Angola and the reported outlawing of Islam in Angola on the plea that the believers of Islam are less than one hundred thousand in that country. AIMMM believes that the criterion fixed by the Government of Angola to recognise a religion is artificial if not outright malicious. AIMMM appeals to the Government of Angola to revise its decision and to accord its Muslim citizens the freedom of religion which is part of the universally-agreed human and civil rights of people in all countries.
Egypt
AIMMM notes that the ruling junta in Egypt is trying to create a new constitution while only last year the country had voted for and adopted a constitution in a free and fair referendum. Overthrow of elected governments is unacceptable in today’s world and popular forces cannot be outlawed by a constitution written by a narrow-based “liberal” westernised elite. The Egyptian army should unconditionally return to the barracks and allow the elected and legal president of the country to resume his duties. 
Gaza Strip
The inhuman and illegal Israeli blockade of Gaza strip continues since 2007. The people in Gaza Strip are suffering and dying as a result of this illegal siege. The people of Gaza had a brief respite under President Morsi of Egypt but since the military coup last July, things have returned to a situation worse than Mubarak days because the army has destroyed most of the tunnels between Gaza and Sinai which were a lifeline for the people of Gaza. Gaza is in dire need of world support to survive and to defeat the brutal Israeli blockade.
  
Syria
AIMMM observes with pain the continued civil war and blood-letting in Syria as a result of foreign support to both sides of the conflict. The situation is worsened by the entry of Al-Qaeda-affiliated terrorists of the so-called “Islamic State of Iraq & Syria” who have muddled a just struggle against a sectarian and dictatorial regime. The AIMMM supports the struggle of the people of Syria to free themselves from the yoke of the sectarian Ba’athist dictatorship and appeals to foreign forces to stop meddling in the affairs of Syria and desist from giving it a sectarian colour.
[end]
Photographsof this meeting are available here: http://www.flickr.com/photos/mushawarat/  [first two rows]

Our Indian Feudal Service - By Shekhar Gupta - The Indian Express, New Delhi, India.

Some questions in public arena:
1.Was Sangeetha a professional maid, or accepted a position with Devyani, with intent to somehow immigrate to US? Her father being in US Consulate in New Delhi, could be fully aware if not helpful in forming an apparent illegal modus operandi to circumvent US immigrant laws. Was there some involvement of New Delhi US consular offices, in aiding and abetting Sangeetha with clear intent to save her and save her entire family by facilitating the rest of the families prompt departure to the US.The case against Devyani could have been an afterthought, when Devyani would have objected to Sangeetha's intent to leave her job with her and try to seek her fortune in US. It is a typical case, how majority of Indian immigrants in Gulf employed by one employer, try illegally to change their employment and immigrant status, by any means available and often fail. In Sangeetha's case, her US lawyer has probably come forward with a clearly ingenious scheme to keep her in US, by making her a victim of employer abuse.

2. Devyani and her consular colleagues and adviser seem to have gone extra vengeful, in first revoking her Indian passport to send her back to India, besides using Indian Judicial process to punish Sangeetha for leaving her job with the 'original sponsor' --- as Gulf people will say. The denial of chances for intending immigrants to find alternate employment or career, may be not legal or contractual, but still very cruel. Why Indian consular authorities have resorted to such heavy handed methods. Is there some personal tiff involved.
3. Why the unusual and un-proportional media and political outrage was unleashed without any need to run the whole affair through usual diplomatic deliberations. Was there any local issues were to be covered up through this hullabaloo?
GM
----- ----- ----- -----

http://www.indianexpress.com/news/national-interest-of-course-they-have-a-right-to-fleece-a-maid-break-the-law-and-claim-immunity/1210149/0

The Indian Express

Our Indian Feudal Service

Shekhar Gupta : Sat Dec 21 2013, 10:35 hrs
Of course, they have a right to fleece a maid, break the law — and claim immunity
Indian diplomacy has a well-deserved reputation for conservative understatedness. You've rarely seen a professional Indian diplomat grandstanding or headline-hunting. Not even Mani Shankar Aiyar, when he enjoyed diplomatic immunity. Probably no one after Krishna Menon's days of acid filibustery more than half a century ago. Not for any "proper" Indian diplomat the arrogant, stupid swagger of the occasional Pakistani — if anybody can recall an Indian insult to rival the unspeakable Munir Akram (later Pakistan representative to the UN) dismissing Salman Khurshid as a rented Muslim, and India as the sick man of Asia, please do let me know and I will stand corrected. To my recollection, the funniest Indian diplomatic comment came from K. Natwar Singh. When asked if he was a hawk or a dove, he said, "I am running foreign policy, not a bird sanctuary." For someone who represented Bharatpur in the Lok Sabha, that was really smart. And the most cutting in recent memory was also possibly the most subtle. As India and Pakistan seemed to be drawing close to war in 2001-02 following the attack on Parliament, Pakistan responded by test-firing several "new" missiles, all named after medieval invaders of India: Abdali, Ghazni, Ghori, etc. Asked for comment at her daily press briefing, Nirupama Rao, then MEA spokesperson, simply said, "We are not impressed". Just four brilliant, inoffensive words were enough to infuriate Pervez Musharraf.

What is to explain such a radical shift in the style and manner of such a classy, sophisticated and patient foreign service bureaucracy? Words like barbaric, despicable, inhuman, perfidy, betrayal, withdraw-all-charges-and-apologise and so on do not belong to the usual diplomatic vocabulary. These are the last resort of editorial writers and TV anchors always short of ideas or a clever turn of phrase. The same foreign service has handled three relatively recent incidents that amount to enormous perfidies — the torture and killing of Captain Saurabh Kalia and his patrol of five in Kargil (June, 1999), the beheading of an Indian soldier and disfiguring of the other on the LoC (January, 2013) and, in between, the greatest and continuing betrayal of all, the American double games over David Coleman Headley — with such mature equanimity.

It is not even as if Indian diplomats haven't been put through harassment and worse in the past. Ravindra Mhatre, our assistant high commissioner in Birmingham, was kidnapped and killed by the JKLF to free Maqbool Butt and much later, following the destruction of Babri Masjid, the residence of our consul-general in Karachi, Rajiv Dogra, was ransacked. But never did our hallowed foreign service reach for the holster as they have done now. Nothing, not the CIA, PLA or ISI has roused this country to come together against a common enemy as this. It took just one perfidious, conspiring maid to stand up and ask for her rights.

This paper hasn't been spared either for daring to advise against going overboard, and for pointing out the inconvenient fact that there is another person, a poor maid, also involved and probably (and I use this line with trepidation as it's been in bad odour lately) there are two versions of this story. Or put it another way. If you wanted to see an entirely new manifestation of journalism of courage, you should have been an Indian Express editorial writer walking through the lawns of Delhi's Hyderabad House on Thursday, peopled by a bevy of MEA officers at the minister's annual year-end lunch for the media. Having survived many sniper alleys in my career, my instincts recognise one almost immediately.
The Devyani Khobragade, or rather the Devyani-Sangeeta (remember, the maid?), case is complex as it involves three tricky factors: class, caste and caste. Wait a few moments for me to explain why I use "caste" twice. Class, because in a row between master and servant, class will always triumph and so Khobragade must be right. Caste, first because Khobragade is from a Dalit family and so the insult is compounded. And caste for the second time because, in the caste hierarchy of sarkar-i-hind, the highest caste of all, the Brahmins of Brahminism, is the Indian Foreign Service. If that upstart Preet Bharara dares to read his rotten Manhattan law to an Indian diplomat, he will be made to pay. Uski naani yaad dila denge. Or maybe even get some uncle of his in Jalandhar or wherever charged with atrocities under the SC/ST act and show him how effectively India's legal reform works. If only when it chooses to. Truth to tell, instead of cursing Bharara, we should try and import him as our first lokpal.

It is early for us to pronounce on the merits of the case yet, except that you cannot deny that there is a case, there are two sides, two versions and two victims. The maid, prima facie, is a victim of awful, callous exploitation, and the diplomat of being subjected to the horrible indignities of America's arrest procedures. We, by the way, are a nation of other extremes. We can't handcuff anybody, not even Ajmal Kasab, so you see these curious pictures of dreaded terrorists and policemen walking to courts hand-in-hand as if in some Jai-and-Veeru bonding. But of course, we make up by routinely torturing, raping and murdering in custody.

It will not be out of place to quote here a comment that New York Times columnist Roger Cohen made to me on a visit to Delhi last week. "Please explain your country to me. You have a Scandinavian rape law and the Russian homosexuality law." But then all our awful laws, sick thana culture, abusive policemen and creative FIR writers are not for PLUs. Definitely not for those on the top of the PLU pyramid. All these are for Sangeeta Richard and her type. Stupid, thieving, lying, free-booting maid types. India's original, and sadly most enduring, idea of our below-stairs class. At least that much that clown Bharara should have known! What happened to his Indian DNA? That is what we are so angry about. Just because they got away with arresting Dominique Strauss-Kahn moments before take-off, in spite of his high diplomatic status, they thought they could touch an Indian. We aren't the bloody French.

Of course, as an Indian, I would also wish that Khobragade is brought back to India, but made to face charges here of allegedly cheating her maid and bringing disrepute to her country by lying on the maid's visa form, if she did that. Chances are, in today's primetime-fuelled hyper-patriotism, she will be hailed as some kind of Jhansi ki Rani. We all know the oft-repeated truism that diplomats are sent abroad to lie for their countries. But are they also paid to lie to their maids, the visa authorities, and then claim immunity? Please tell me another. And please think twice before you can accuse an honest taxpayer like me, armed with no immunity other than what Article 19 of the Constitution gives 120 crore Indians, of carrying a chip on the shoulder about the IFS ('It's a chip', Rajiv Sikri, IE, December 19) for raising these simple points. Sangeeta Richard is Indian too, and poor or rich, must have the same rights as Khobragade.

This case has stumped the political establishment as well. The UPA displays so much fake anger, you wonder when will it rescind the nuclear deal. Khurshid said he won't come to Parliament until Her Excellency the Acting Consul General's honour is restored. Did he think of making some similar sacrifice to restore the dignity of 50,000 Muslims in the camps of Muzaffarnagar, 150 km away? Particularly when he represents Farrukhabad, not so far from there. As for our left-liberal bleeding hearts, they still can't figure out whether to fight for a poor member of The Great Unwashed or take on The Great Satan. And, since I am being so reckless, let me also ask another trick question. Where did your Indian pride and self-respect go when you silently congratulated the same Americans for denying a visa to Narendra Modi? Whatever your political differences, he is a leader elected to a high political office in India. If he can visit 7 Race Course Road or Vigyan Bhawan, he cannot be barred from visiting Washington. And if he is, we should at least make the pretence of protest. So let's not talk again about national pride and diplomatic propriety. Let's also not kid ourselves into believing that employing house maids is some kind of universal human right.

In a conversation the other night with a greatly respected former Indian civil servant, I learnt the history of the barricades in front of the US embassy in Delhi. A security review was carried out after the US embassy in Nairobi was bombed on August 7, 1998. The Delhi mission had no protection from such an attack, so a joint India-US team suggested putting up "Jersey" barriers, the heavy but movable concrete blocks so called because they were first used on the New Jersey turnpike. The MEA objected because it feared that every embassy would demand this. But L.K. Advani was advised by his key aides to overrule it, and he wisely did. Sushilkumar Shinde should have checked the files before getting these removed. And our churlish incompetence is only matched by America's stupidity. Why didn't they simply retaliate by shutting down the visa section until security was restored? The tone of primetime discussions would have changed overnight. How would you keep all those mummyjis, daddyjis and auntyjis away from their betajis in Christmas season?

sg@expressindia.com


----- ----- -----