The old lady of Bori Bandar doth protest too much! - By Ghulam Muhammed

Friday, November 05, 2010

The old lady of Bori Bandar doth protest too much!

While it is laudable that The Times of India and its most effective new channel, TIMES NOW, have taken up the corruption scandal around the spurious allotments of luxury flats in Adarsh Housing Society’s Tower at prime location in posh southern Mumbai area of Colaba ---- each apartment costing Crores of rupees, for a pittance of its market value, to Army personnel, politicians and bureaucrats, bending all rules and regulations; the week long campaign, both in front pages of Times and in prime time coverage on TIMES NOW channel, gives an appearance of some hidden agenda behind the seemingly noble act of exposing corruption in government circles.

The Old Lady of Bori Bandar, the nickname with which Times of India is known, does seem to protest too much --- to borrow the Shakespeare phrase. And that robs her of all her credibility.

Hasan Kamaal, an old Urdu Blitz editor and a seasoned media analyst in his editorial in Mumbai’s Urdu daily, Sahafat explains: The way a section of media, especially a big English newspaper and its English news channel is exerting all its power on exposing Adarsh Society scandal, it appears their objective is something else………. This section of the media is trying to drown out the scandal of horse trading and ‘Operation Lotus’ in the recent Karnataka upheaval, by their earsplitting cacophony on Adarsh Society scandal. (Free translation from Urdu).

While for people, the voice of media is regarded as speaking for the people, the way the so-called paid media is operating in India, its activity is bordering on criminality. It is covering up a major scandal that threatens the democratic institutions and thus encourages by default, if not be design, the corruption that is the core cancer of our society --- the political corruption of robbing or distorting the people’s mandate in myriad ways of short cuts and manipulations.

It is for people to judge, who is doing the more poisonous corruption, the corruption involving country’s resources, the corruption involving nation’s governance, or the corruption involving people’s brainwashing.

By selling out its commitment to be a bridge between the masses and the ruling classes, media has become more of a liability than an asset to the civil society. A more vigorous campaign should be initiated to expose the criminality of the paid press, which is abusing the trust of the people and indulging in activities in hiding the truth or at least the whole of the truth.

The immediate result of TOI/TIMES NOW campaign is the hardening of Congress High Command resolve to treat the exposing of Adarsh Society scandal as well as Commonwealth Games scandal running into thousands of Crores, as political gimmickry favouring BJP in its own political scandal of horse trading and buying of opposition members to prop up its majority in Karnataka assembly. TOI and TIME NOW are playing partisan games, that is sure to result in the serious erosion of their credibility with their readership and their viewers who are not necessarily in the Saffron camp, in which TOI/TIMES NOW are now stealthily sliding in.

Ghulam Muhammed, Mumbai

ghulammuhammed3@gmail.com

<http://www.ghulammuhammed.blogspot.com>

About 50 radicals linked to Hindu extremism, say officials - By Sahil Makkar - LIVEMINT.COM

http://epaper.livemint.com/ArticleText.aspx?article=04_11_2010_006_011&kword=&mode=1

TERROR MENACE -

About 50 radicals linked to Hindu extremism, say officials

BY SAHIL MAKKAR sahil.m@livemint.com ·························

························· NEW DELHI

Investigators estimate up to 50 people could be linked with Hindu extremism and in- volved in terror acts such as the blasts at the Ajmer dargah and Hyderabad's Mecca Masjid in 2007 and Malegaon in Mahar- ashtra a year later. They are also widening their probe against radical Hindus to include more incidents of vio- lence that took place over the past four years, such as last month's shootout near Delhi's Jama Masjid, in which two for- eigners were injured. “Our estimate is that they (Hindu extremists) are around 30 to 50 in number and scat- tered across the country. Many of them have been arrested, but quite a few are still at large. Also, there are some communal groups, but it is not clear how many of them are terrorists. It should not be more than a handful of people,“ a senior Union home ministry official who is handling such cases, said, requesting anonymity. This is the first time the home ministry has assessed the num- ber of people who could be in- volved in such anti-national ac- tivities. The phenomenon came to light when the Maharashtra Anti-Terrorist Squad (ATS) ar- rested 11 people for the 29 September 2008 blast at Malegaon, in which six people were killed. Among those arrested by the ATS were retired Lt Col Prasad S. Purohit, who had floated the Hindu nationalist organization Abhinav Bharat in 2007; Sadhvi Pragya Singh Thakur, who al- legedly mobilized foot soldiers; and Dayanand Pandey, said to have motivated the conspiracy. Rakesh Dhawade allegedly made arrangements for training those who carried out the blasts, and Ajay Rahirkar is sus- pected of raising funds. Thakur is a former member of the national executive of the Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Pari- shad (ABVP)--the student wing of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), which is widely regarded as the ideological par- ent of many Hindu social, cul- tural and political organiza- tions, including the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). RSS spokesman Ram Madhav described it as a political at- tempt to defame his organiza- tion. “We will protest this by launching nationwide protest on 10 November. We deny all charges made against our or- ganization and men,“ he said. Professor Sudha Pai of the Centre for Political Studies at Jawahar Lal Nehru University (JNU) said the RSS does not have the history of getting into terrorism. “They may communalize and definitely had a hand in the de- molition of the Babri Masjid. There could be small fringe ele- ments that could be involved. There could be a few disgrun- tled people, but the RSS cannot be behind all such activities,“ she said. “I think (the ) Congress is po- liticizing the issue by using it against the BJP, which has now started distancing itself from such organizations,“ she added. The investigators of the Malegaon blast realized the same set of people were also behind the Ajmer and Hydera- bad blasts. Devendra Gupta, a former RSS member who is an accused in the Ajmer blast, confessed to the police that the conspiracy was hatched and executed by Sunil Joshi, Sandeep Dange, Ramji Kalsangra and Lokesh Sharma. While Joshi was mur- dered, Kalsangra and Sharma have been arrested and chargesheeted. Dange is ab- sconding. Gupta was close to Joshi, who had floated the radi- cal outfit Jai Vande Mataram along with Sadhvi Pragya. According to the Rajasthan ATS chargesheet, a self-styled godman called Swami Aseema- nand from the Dangs in Gujarat has emerged as a key figure in the planning and execution of bombings. He brought together Purohit and Sadhvi Pragya, who eventually merged their groups. Aseemanand's arrest, officials say, is crucial to uncovering the entire network of Hindu ex- tremism. The home ministry official quoted earlier said there is no proof that senior office bearers of the RSS and affiliated organi- zations such as the Vishwa Hin- du Parishad and Bajrang Dal are involved in terror activities. “We believe that a handful of people in these organizations are hardcore and radicals.“ Senior RSS leader Indresh Kumar has also been named in the ATS chargesheet, although some officials close to the in- vestigation say there isn't enough proof to nail him. “As of now, there is not enough evidence against In- dresh to chargesheet him as an accused,“ said a senior official at the Central Bureau of Inves- tigation (CBI), which is probing the Mecca Masjid blast. “We are waiting for the ATS to complete its investigation. We will question Indresh once their investigation is complet- ed,“ the official said, adding that the same group was behind the Malegaon, Ajmer and Mec- ca Masjid blasts. Kumar denied the charges levelled against him. “The mat- ter is in court. Let the court de- cide whether I am guilty,“ he said. Home minister P. Chidambaram had warned top police officers at a conference in August to be cautious with regard to Hindu extremism. Another home ministry offi- cial, who also did not want to be identified, said: “It is a very disturbing phenomenon that people from the majority com- munity are adopting extremist ideology. But the government believes that once the people who are at large get arrested and trials of other accused start in court, chances are less that these people would regroup.“ An intelligence bureau offi- cial, who monitors radical groups, agreed that once arrest- ed, these people will not re- group. “But there is no guaran- tee that people in future will not take it (Hindu extremism) up. We got up late to such kind of extremism, but are now keeping a close tab on such ac- tivities.“ The official added that some retired military officers and bu- reaucrats are sympathizers of these groups. “They get money through NGOs (non-govern- mental organizations) and groups like Abhinav Bharat acts as a platform for radicals to come together.“ S.D. Pradhan, a former depu- ty national security adviser, said the agenda of Hindu terror groups seems to be revenge against the “minority commu- nity for the terrorist attacks where most of the victims be- long to the majority communi- ty“. He was referring to a series of terror attacks carried out by Muslim groups in recent years. Probe agencies such as the National Investigation Agency, which was formed to look into terror cases in the wake of the Mumbai attack, are now ex- panding their probe against Hindu extremism. Indian Mujahideen, a Mus- lim terror group, was initially linked with last month's shoot- ing near Delhi's Jama Masjid. But some investigating officials said their probe is now leading them towards Hindu radicals. Appu Esthose Suresh contrib- uted to the story.

Investigators estimate up to 50 people could be linked with Hindu extremism and in- volved in terror acts such as the blasts at the Ajmer dargah and Hyderabad's Mecca Masjid in 2007 and Malegaon in Mahar- ashtra a year later. They are also widening their probe against radical Hindus to include more incidents of vio- lence that took place over the past four years, such as last month's shootout near Delhi's Jama Masjid, in which two for- eigners were injured. “Our estimate is that they (Hindu extremists) are around 30 to 50 in number and scat- tered across the country. Many of them have been arrested, but quite a few are still at large. Also, there are some communal groups, but it is not clear how many of them are terrorists. It should not be more than a handful of people,“ a senior Union home ministry official who is handling such cases, said, requesting anonymity. This is the first time the home ministry has assessed the num- ber of people who could be in- volved in such anti-national ac- tivities. The phenomenon came to light when the Maharashtra Anti-Terrorist Squad (ATS) ar- rested 11 people for the 29 September 2008 blast at Malegaon, in which six people were killed. Among those arrested by the ATS were retired Lt Col Prasad S. Purohit, who had floated the Hindu nationalist organization Abhinav Bharat in 2007; Sadhvi Pragya Singh Thakur, who al- legedly mobilized foot soldiers; and Dayanand Pandey, said to have motivated the conspiracy. Rakesh Dhawade allegedly made arrangements for training those who carried out the blasts, and Ajay Rahirkar is sus- pected of raising funds. Thakur is a former member of the national executive of the Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Pari- shad (ABVP)--the student wing of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), which is widely regarded as the ideological par- ent of many Hindu social, cul- tural and political organiza- tions, including the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). RSS spokesman Ram Madhav described it as a political at- tempt to defame his organiza- tion. “We will protest this by launching nationwide protest on 10 November. We deny all charges made against our or- ganization and men,“ he said. Professor Sudha Pai of the Centre for Political Studies at Jawahar Lal Nehru University (JNU) said the RSS does not have the history of getting into terrorism. “They may communalize and definitely had a hand in the de- molition of the Babri Masjid. There could be small fringe ele- ments that could be involved. There could be a few disgrun- tled people, but the RSS cannot be behind all such activities,“ she said. “I think (the ) Congress is po- liticizing the issue by using it against the BJP, which has now started distancing itself from such organizations,“ she added. The investigators of the Malegaon blast realized the same set of people were also behind the Ajmer and Hydera- bad blasts. Devendra Gupta, a former RSS member who is an accused in the Ajmer blast, confessed to the police that the conspiracy was hatched and executed by Sunil Joshi, Sandeep Dange, Ramji Kalsangra and Lokesh Sharma. While Joshi was mur- dered, Kalsangra and Sharma have been arrested and chargesheeted. Dange is ab- sconding. Gupta was close to Joshi, who had floated the radi- cal outfit Jai Vande Mataram along with Sadhvi Pragya. According to the Rajasthan ATS chargesheet, a self-styled godman called Swami Aseema- nand from the Dangs in Gujarat has emerged as a key figure in the planning and execution of bombings. He brought together Purohit and Sadhvi Pragya, who eventually merged their groups. Aseemanand's arrest, officials say, is crucial to uncovering the entire network of Hindu ex- tremism. The home ministry official quoted earlier said there is no proof that senior office bearers of the RSS and affiliated organi- zations such as the Vishwa Hin- du Parishad and Bajrang Dal are involved in terror activities. “We believe that a handful of people in these organizations are hardcore and radicals.“ Senior RSS leader Indresh Kumar has also been named in the ATS chargesheet, although some officials close to the in- vestigation say there isn't enough proof to nail him. “As of now, there is not enough evidence against In- dresh to chargesheet him as an accused,“ said a senior official at the Central Bureau of Inves- tigation (CBI), which is probing the Mecca Masjid blast. “We are waiting for the ATS to complete its investigation. We will question Indresh once their investigation is complet- ed,“ the official said, adding that the same group was behind the Malegaon, Ajmer and Mec- ca Masjid blasts. Kumar denied the charges levelled against him. “The mat- ter is in court. Let the court de- cide whether I am guilty,“ he said. Home minister P.Chidambaram had warned top police officers at a conference in August to be cautious with regard to Hindu extremism. Another home ministry offi- cial, who also did not want to be identified, said: “It is a very disturbing phenomenon that people from the majority com- munity are adopting extremist ideology. But the government believes that once the people who are at large get arrested and trials of other accused start in court, chances are less that these people would regroup.“ An intelligence bureau offi- cial, who monitors radical groups, agreed that once arrest- ed, these people will not re- group. “But there is no guaran- tee that people in future will not take it (Hindu extremism) up. We got up late to such kind of extremism, but are now keeping a close tab on such ac- tivities.“ The official added that some retired military officers and bu- reaucrats are sympathizers of these groups. “They get money through NGOs (non-govern- mental organizations) and groups like Abhinav Bharat acts as a platform for radicals to come together.“ S.D. Pradhan, a former depu- ty national security adviser, said the agenda of Hindu terror groups seems to be revenge against the “minority commu- nity for the terrorist attacks where most of the victims be- long to the majority communi- ty“. He was referring to a series of terror attacks carried out by Muslim groups in recent years. Probe agencies such as the National Investigation Agency, which was formed to look into terror cases in the wake of the Mumbai attack, are now ex- panding their probe against Hindu extremism. Indian Mujahideen, a Mus- lim terror group, was initially linked with last month's shoot- ing near Delhi's Jama Masjid. But some investigating officials said their probe is now leading them towards Hindu radicals. Appu Esthose Suresh contrib- uted to the story. EMAIL sahil.m@livemint.com