Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Understanding the Mumbai violence - By Amaresh Misra - Times of India | BLOGS

http://blogs.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/the-mainstream-maverick/entry/understanding-mumbai-violence


The Times of India   | BLOGS




Understanding the Mumbai violence

Amaresh Misra
14 August 2012, 06:04 PM IST
0
On 10th August 2012, I was sitting with a bureaucrat friend of mine, in a Delhi restaurant. This friend occupies an important position in the government connected with maintaining law and order. We were discussing my blog post - Pune Blasts: The Story Behind the Story”. At one point in the article I elaborate upon the chilling fourth degree torture unleashed allegedly under the overall superintendence of Rakesh Maria—the current Maharashtra ATS chief—way back in 1993—on the kin of the 1993 Mumbai blast.

The alleged torture story is truly horrific and contains unspeakable instances of state-sponsored sadism on men, women and children.
Our conversation drifted to the framing of innocent Muslim youth in terror cases—the most glaring of which remains the 2008 Malegaon blast instance. Here, even after the late Hemant Karkare exposed the hand of right-wing, Sangh Parivar backed terrorism behind the blasts, Muslims initially charged with the crime—in which nearly all victims were Muslims—were not let off till 2012—and that too only on bail.

The said bureaucrat was worried over several Malegaon blast type incidents existing in India—and the deep sense of alienation that Muslim youths are passing through. At one point, I remarked in the usual arm chair discussion mode that “what will happen if 25 crore Indian Muslims decide to revolt?”

My friend replied calmly that forget about crores—the Indian security apparatus will not be able to handle even a 10,000 strong, militant crowd.

Next day, on 11th August 2012, my friend’s words came back to haunt me as I saw the footage of not more than 500-1000 people, thrashing up the police, media and anyone who came their way.

This aggressive mass had emerged from a 50,000 strong gathering at Azad Maidan, Mumbai, called by different Muslim groups such as the Raza Academy to protest against Assam ethnic violence and the systematic killing of Rohingiya Muslims in Myanmar.

Now, newspaper reports/commentators are talking about the hidden NCP-Congress fight in Mumbai; how the Raza Academy group of maulavis are close to NCP; and how the Azad Maidan protest was used by Sharad Pawar to shift focus away from the investigations (of corruption charges) against a NCP minister and the like.

As an active participant in several mass movements—some of which I actually led in my capacity as a Left student leader of Allahabad University—a campus famous for anti-establishment student militancy—I could not but express scepticism at the NCP-conspiracy angle. I remember in 1985, the students of Allahabad University had organized a massive movement against fee rise; ordinary students—some of them toppers of their disciplines—fought the police for hours with nothing but stones—so much so that several companies of the famed Provincial Armed Constabulary (PAC) of Uttar Pradesh had to retreat, not once but twice.

During the 1985 Allahabad movement, several elements who kept hand-made guns (katta) and hand-made bombs in their rooms (a normal practice in Uttar Pradesh campus’ at least till the 1990s), too came out to fight when the PAC started invading hostels and beating up the students mercilessly in the lathi-charge melee.

Bombs were thrown—guns were fired—at PAC jawans. All this was done without exception by senior, upper caste Hindu boys, dominating the hostels, some of whom had clear, but small time, criminal connections.

Yet, guns and bombs constituted less than 5 per cent of the student upsurge. The nature of mass movements is such that all elements of society—including the criminal-lumpen constituent—tend to participate. But ordinary people/students/youngsters always—without exception—form the bulk.

Things have changed quite a lot since the 1980s and 1990s. Indeed, the last 15 years has not seen a major mass movement even in Uttar Pradesh and Bihar, the traditional hotbeds of turbulence. I think media—which has emerged as a phenomenal force in precisely these 15 years—suffers from a lack of experience and perspective as far as mass movements and actions are concerned.

In politics as well, a new breed of managerial-technocrat—yuppies and foreign educated—politicians have emerged. They dominate nearly all parties. Let alone mass movements and mass actions, they do not understand mass dynamics. In 2011, they failed terribly in reading the dynamics behind the Anna phenomenon. In 2012, incidents at Manesar and Mumbai leave them speechless.

This is unfortunate. The attitude which sees politics as an entity that can be `managed’—or masses as consumers who can be manipulated into buying poll promises—misses the entire point.

Several 21st Century, fab-india jholawala types—not Leftists but NGO marka activists—also suffer deeply from this malaise. These elements see masses as objects of suffering, passive and bhola-bhala. They commit the fatal mistake of viewing violence or aggression as some outside impulse, brought into a mass action either by vested interests or certain lobbies and so on and forth.

Violence and aggression are part and parcel of mass movements/actions. After an incident of mass violence in Chauri Chaura, Gorakhpur, Mahatama Gandhi withdrew the non-cooperation movement in 1921. But the same Mahatama did not utter a word of condemnation of the massive violence unleashed by the Indian people against the British colonial State in 1942.

After Independence, though violence remained part of mass movements and actions, the art of negotiation and growth of leaders who could talk to—or listen to—masses—minimised to a great degree the role of bloodshed. However since the late 1990s—the art of going deep into the people—entering people’s homes during election campaigns to have a cup of tea—and occurrences of leaders breaking security cordons to shake hands with the people—allowing literally the tearing apart of their kurtas—has vanished.

Especially in the 2000s, political leaders have ceded the middle ground of interacting with the people, going on padyatras and the like. Even when they take such initiatives, it is for a limited period of time. In some cases, it even appears pretentious.

Mumbai violence essentially emerged out of the pent-up rage of Muslim youth. The brutal killings in Assam and Myanmar may have served as a trigger—and yes, some lumpen elements were definitely present to add fuel to fire. But serious issues should not be reduced to mere manifestations—one has to understand the reasons behind incidents of mass violence.

There is something seriously sick with a society that allows 4,00,000 of its own citizens to live like animals in Assam in relief camps—and does not condemn the planned violence unleashed on them by trained anti-national militias. Instead, political leaders are seen harping on the illegal immigration issue—forgetting conveniently that at least 20-30 per cent of the 400,000 people living in camps in Assam are Bengali Hindus, Santhals or Biharis.

A society which looks the other way when haves unleash violence on the have-nots has no business complaining when the have-nots retaliate. In Manesar we saw how while the profits of Maruti Suzuki soared by 2200 per cent, wages of workers stagnated at 5.5 percent.

Violence is written in the script of the new India that emerges following the liberalization process. In Manesar, many workers who took part in the movement are graduates—in Mumbai and other metros, a new generation of Muslims—with university degrees, skills, MBAs up their sleeves—have emerged. The material wealth around them has made their aspirations run high. They want more—and unlike their fathers or grandfathers—they are vocal and aggressive about their wants. But the delivery is poor. Most of the educated Muslims still live in ghettos and slums where basic amenities like electricity, water, health centres are missing. They seldom see the face of their local body representative, MLA or MP. Unlike the old days, there is no one to organize at least a meeting in their locality, to express shame and regret, at say, Assam type killings.

On the other hand, these youths have mobiles and can access the internet. They are tech savvy; when the political class fails to address them, they go by what they see on the screen or what they hear from their mobile phones. Why will they not react with violence?

Right wing bloggers will now say that the combination of education, technology and backwardness is not particular to Muslims. True, this is a general Indian phenomenon. That is why I quoted Manesar where 95 per cent workers are Hindus of different castes. So don’t say that Muslims resort to violence because their ideology or religion says so—try instead, to understand—irrespective of caste or creed—the social roots of contemporary violence in all its shades and complexity.


Monday, August 13, 2012

Déjà vu in Mumbai - Editorial - THE HINDU, Chennai, INDIA

Comments posted on THE HINDU website over Editorial: Déjà vu in Mumbai

It is not déjà vu. Never in the past has such violence been unleashed by Muslims in the city. Even the 1989 protest march against Rushdie's book was peaceful until a political decision by Sharad Pawar translated into a shooting spree by a communal police commissioner in charge. Pawar's worry was that such huge crowd was organised by politically lightweight Muslim leaders, threatening his own Muslim proxies. Currently too, there is clear sign that the group - Brelvis were more aligned to Sharad Pawar's NCP and it is widely believed Sharad Pawar was raring for a showdown with Congress, its coalition partner, who were investigating a big irrigation scandal by a NCP minister. Hindu has clear independence to go deeper into the news and views beyond the news and views that seems to become stereo-type coverage of Muslim affairs. Muslims are not allowed to have an independent existence, without first paying their dues to the political parties. Hindu must probe and boldly report all sides.

from:  Ghulam Muhammed
Posted on: Aug 13, 2012 at 14:43 IST

------------------------------

PS : Brelvis themselves were led up the garden path. Their meeting was hijacked by professional goons.

                              Bottom of Form
Return to frontpage                     

Opinion » Editorial

August 13, 2012

Déjà vu in Mumbai

Share  ·   Comment (4)   ·   print   ·   T+  

Saturday’s arson and vandalism during protests by Muslim groups against the ethnic killings in Assam and Myanmar caught the Mumbai police on the wrong foot, and not for the first time. The violence erupted despite advance intelligence reports and the deployment of an 800-strong police force and is a sad commentary on the state of law and order management in the city. Inflammatory speeches by irresponsible Muslim ‘leaders’ goaded the crowds to go on a rampage, burning media OB vans and vehicles, smashing buses and paralysing South Mumbai for a while. The police itself bore the brunt of the mob’s fury. The manner in which the violence unfolded points to pre-planned disruption and even city police commissioner Arup Patnaik, who made an attempt to pacify the crowds, admitted it was a close call. The media too came under fire and had to run for cover with many photographers and TV crew assaulted. While the madness lasted, a sense of insecurity and terror prevailed in the city with protesters taking over local trains and, for a while, the roads in front of Azad Maidan. For a police force that had reasons to fear the rally might end in violence, the failure to deploy and plan adequately was glaring.

That is not to say that political protests — even those built around the emotional pull of religious solidarity — must not be allowed in the city. In the past too, the roads of Mumbai and the sprawling Azad Maidan have been jammed with Muslim groups demonstrating against the Iraq war and earlier over the Supreme Court's Shah Bano judgment. Despite the overwhelming numbers, the protests were peaceful except during the 1989 rally in Bhendi Bazar against Salman Rushdie’s book, The Satanic Verses, which resulted in nine deaths in police firing. After that, Mumbai witnessed its worst communal carnage in 1992-93 in which hundreds of Muslims lost their lives. In the 20 years after the riots, the city has witnessed many bomb blasts after its first in 1993, the terror strike of 2008 and the serial blasts last year. There is a sense of fear, especially among Muslims, after each bomb blast since they are on the radar of suspicion. The failure of the criminal justice system to punish the instigators and facilitators of the 1992-93 violence also rankles them. This is the emotional terrain that self-styled community leaders and aspiring politicians are quick to cash in on by playing on the insecurities of the Muslim community. Saturday’s violence could well be the result of such mischievous instigation. Chief Minister Prithviraj Chavan must now take swift action against these vested interests and prevent the city from turning into a cauldron of hate.

Keywords: Assam riots, Mumbai protest, Azad Maidan Ground

Comments:

Why would Muslims in Mumbai indulge in unruly violence to protest against alleged killings of Muslims in Assam and Myanmar? Feeling of insecurity, as stated by you, could be one of the many reasons. But surely, these are not local Muslims or else they should have protested about more valid reasons rather than alleged violence in far away Assam or Myanmar ( a foreign country). What is the country having common borders with both Assam and Myanmar? The answer is Bangla Desh. Why were these protestors having more affinity towards issues pertaining to Bangla Desh rather than towards the local issues? This is a matter of investigation.
from:  Pramod Patil
Posted on: Aug 13, 2012 at 06:21 IST

Police and state intellgence have bene caught napping. In such
agitations for which thousands travel in groups in suburban traisn,
there is a laot of advance indication. People trek from trains right
from 1 am onwards. The precise questrion is on the issue of police
lack of alertness and not being rpeapred to meet the situation. All
these potential demonstrators congregated in VCST station. EVEN TGHEN
POLICE DID NOT GET ALERTED AND AUGMENT THE FORCES. the result the mayhem in A MAIDAN. politcal accountability demands the home minsiter's resignation.
from:  s.subramanyan
Posted on: Aug 13, 2012 at 10:01 IST

Its a matter of deep concern that self-styled leaders hijack the collective thinking of Muslims and do not allow individual perspective to take root.What pains me more is the concern for 'Muslims' and not Indians.Had it been a protest against communal violence,it would have had credibility and support of all. This sectarian approach has alsways hindered the Muslim integration in the main stream and will continue to do so until we have minority leaders with nationalistic outlook.

from:  Apurv Sharma
Posted on: Aug 13, 2012 at 10:23 IST


It is not deja vu. Never in the past such violence has been unleashed by Muslims in the city. Even the 1989 protest march against Rushdie's book was peaceful until a political decision by Sharad Pawar translated into a shooting spree by a communal police commissioner in charge. Pawar's worry was that such huge crowd was organised by politically lightweight Muslim leaders, threatening his own Muslim proxies. Currently too, there is clear sign that the group - Brelvis were more aligned to Sharad Pawar's NCP and it is widely believed Sharad Pawar was raring for a showdown with Congress, its coalition partner, who were investigating a big irrigation scandal by a NCP minister. Hindu has clear independence to go deeper into the news and views beyond the news and views that seems to become a stereo-type coverage of Muslim affairs. Muslims are not allowed to have an independent existence, without first paying their dues to the political parties. Hindu must probe and boldly report all sides.

from:  Ghulam Muhammed
Posted on: Aug 13, 2012 at 14:43 IST
                            

Saturday, August 11, 2012

16 injured as anti-Assam riot protest turns ugly in Mumbai - THE INDIAN EXPRESS, MUMBAI

IF CONGRESS GOVERNMENT IN MUMBAI ALLOWS POLICE TO SHOOT AT MUSLIMS ON THE RAMPAGE, WHY CAN'T ANOTHER CONGRESS GOVERNMENT IN ASSAM ALLOW POLICE TO SHOOT BODOS WHEN THEY GO ON RAMPAGE IN ASSAM KILLING MUSLIMS?
GHULAM MUHAMMED, MUMBAI

-----------------------------------------------------

http://www.indianexpress.com/news/16-injured-as-antiassam-riot-protest-turns-ugly-in-mumbai/987080/0

The Indian Express

16 injured as anti-Assam riot protest turns ugly in Mumbai

Agencies : Mumbai, Sat Aug 11 2012, 18:11


At least 16 persons were injured when a protest against Assam riots today turned violent as protesters set fire to vehicles, including media vans, and pelted stones, leading the police to fire in the air and use batons to the disperse the unruly mob here.

Hundreds of protesters gathered at the Azad Maidan Ground in south Mumbai this afternoon on a call given by a city-based outfit, Raza Academy, to denounce the riots in Assam and also alleged attacks on a minority community in neighbouring Myanmar.

They suddenly turned unruly and torched vehicles, damaged buses and pelted stones. Police opened fire in the air and resorted to lathi-charge to disperse the mob and restore order, said a policeman deployed at the Azad Maidan.

Azad Maidan Ground, a regular venue for protests, is located near Mumbai civic body headquarters and CST Mumbai railway station. The bustling area wore a deserted look as policemen cordoned off the locality and patrolled the streets.

At least 16 people, including some media persons, were injured. The situation has been brought under control, police said, adding cause of the violence was being probed.

Due to the unrest, several suburban train services were briefly disrupted and road traffic was also affected.

Eight of the injured were rushed to St George Hospital while four each were taken to G T and J J Hospitals, officials at Disaster Control Room said.

"Three media OB vans and a police vehicle were set on fire. A BEST (civic) bus, two four-wheelers and five two-wheelers were damaged in the stone pelting," they stated.

Meanwhile, Raza Academy distanced itself from the violence. "While we were protesting at the ground, some people got aggressive and started behaving violently," Mohammed Saeed, General Secretary of the academy, said.

"We never encourage violence and strongly condemn such acts," he added.

Thursday, August 9, 2012

MY TODAY'S TWEETS: August 10, 2012

MY TODAY'S TWEETS: August 10, 2012


Tweets
1m Ghulam Muhammed Ghulam Muhammed ‏@GhulamMuhammed

If Assam govt cannot protect its citizens, it should let them arm to protect themselves.
Expand

    Reply
    Delete
    Favorite

3m Ghulam Muhammed Ghulam Muhammed ‏@GhulamMuhammed

@ZeeNews If you work hard at stealing, may be you 'deserve' more.
View conversation

    Reply
    Delete
    Favorite

4m Ghulam Muhammed Ghulam Muhammed ‏@GhulamMuhammed

LK ADVANI hides his communalism by pushing his ethnic cleansing on the basis of Hindu immigrants welcome, Muslims unwelcome; old RSS agenda.
Expand

    Reply
    Delete
    Favorite

8m Ghulam Muhammed Ghulam Muhammed ‏@GhulamMuhammed

Times of India editorially turns dictatorial advising Govt ignore overwhelming opposition to Wall-mart and Carrefor as its legally empowered
Expand

Why a Dallas UM pastor is observing the Muslim fast of Ramadan

http://www.examiner.com/article/kera-exclusive-dallas-muslims-inspired-embracing-the-ramadan-fasting-um-pastor

Why a Dallas UM pastor is observing the Muslim fast of Ramadan

United Methodist Rev. Wess Magruder has not only decided to observe the Ramadan fast this year with his Muslim friends, blog about his experience, but break his fast with Muslims as well. Last night, Magruder accepted the invitation of a local Muslim to eat “iftar,” the fast-breaking meal at the McKinney Islamic Association. Having succeeded in fasting from sunrise till sunset for eight consecutive days, the pastor appreciated God's grace in this communal meal. Most importantly, this celebration reminded him of the main reason why he had decided to fast: neighborly love.
Magruder writes on his blog how he has been feeling spiritually stale lately and how he was yearning to the old Christian fast that he believes Americans are not big fans of. Therefore, Magruder turned to the Muslim faith for inspiration since he knew that Muslims have successfully been fasting for 30 days each year during Ramadan for over fourteen hundred years. The Muslim fast is a total abstention from eating and drinking during the daylight hours. Furthermore, the fast goes beyond the stomach to include the eyes, the tongue, the ears, and all limbs which are expected to be trained to submit to the pleasure of God by refraining from ill manners and moral vice. A few Muslims succeed in attaining a heart-fast where they become spiritually submissive to the divine as well.


Thus, Magruder’s blog includes a lot of comparative religion as well as spiritual efforts for a quest for the Divine. "I feel a constant “buzz” [during the fast] in my head," he wrote. "This buzz serves a useful purpose, by the way. It keeps me conscious of God, of God’s presence, of God’s will that is bursting to become real in the world. And so when something else isn’t going on in front of me, the buzz reminds me to speak to God."

Another main reason that the pastor took on the Muslim fast is his Christian ethics of loving God and loving neighbors. “But there’s another reason that I have chosen to ‘act like a Muslim’ over the next thirty days. I truly want to stand in solidarity with my friend, [Imam Sheikh] Yaseen, and his congregation in Plano. I want them to know that I do not resent their presence in my community and country. In fact, I am very glad that they are here.” (The New MethoFesto)

Not realizing what his blogging experience might trigger, Rev. Magruder woke up on July 26, the seventh day of Ramadan, to a flooded email inbox with comments from his blog. His blog posts have been picked up by local Muslims and Christians as well as by nation-wide readers who sent words of encouragement, advice, and support. The Huffington Post Ramadan Liveblog even included his posts. “I am overwhelmed by the response,” Magruder wrote.

Most Muslim commentators gave the pastor “high fives,” advice on surviving the fast, and thank you notes for sharing the experience online. One particular reader, Osman, invited Magruder to the break-fasting meal at the McKinney mosque mentioned earlier. 

Thus, this individual initiative on the part of a loving Christian neighbor was received with outpouring love and compassion and resulted in more friendships.

However, not all blog readers are Muslim. A few are Christian fellows who appreciated Magruder’s initiative in building bridges within the Abrahamic faith and in sharing the Muslim experience. 

Others were not quite impressed as they believed that this fast is a tough one and meaningless. Some non-Muslim readers also expressed their critical views about Islam and Muslim countries like Saudi Arabia as far as tolerance and the status of women. In a nut shell, the blog turned out to be an interfaith dialog where people from every faith contribute a thought or two and carry on a civilized conversation.

The DFW Muslim community has always been blessed with friendships, alliances, and bridges it shares with the larger American community. But this year, as more non-Muslims like Rev. Magruder are choosing to observe the Ramadan fast with Muslims as signs of compassion and solidarity, American Muslims locally and nationally are appreciative of such initiatives to close gaps between faith traditions and bring more understanding to our nation. American Muslims know that they are not alone in fasting this year because they are home.

Wednesday, August 8, 2012

A truly inspirational story

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: <>
Date: Wed, Aug 1, 2012 at 3:51 PM
Subject: Bismillah [MuslimCity]: A truly inspirational story
To: eGroup For Muslims Around The World <muslimcity@yahoogroups.com>


 
Subhanallah
 
Below is a must read link to a truly inspirational story
http://veiledmuslimah.wordpress.com/2012/07/02/the-husband-who-was-too-shy-t
o-look-at-his-wife-a-moving-story/

Shahnaaz Bemath's Blog

ISLAM is not about we are better THAN you. ISLAM is all about ''let me show
you something that is better FOR you."

The Husband Who Was Too Shy To Look At His Wife (a moving story)

This story was recounted by Prof. Khalid Al-Jubeir, consulting
cardiovascular surgeon, in one of his lectures:

Once I operated on a two and a half year old child. It was Tuesday, and on
Wednesday the child was in good health. On Thursday at 11:15 am - and I'll
never forget the time because of the shock I experienced - one of the nurses
informed me that the heart and breathing of the child had stopped. I hurried
to the child and performed cardiac massage for 45 minutes and during that
entire time the heart would not work.

Then, ALLAH decreed for the heart to resume function and we thanked HIM. I
went to inform the child's family about his condition. As you know, it is
very difficult to inform the patient's family about his condition when it's
bad. This is one of the most difficult situations a doctor is subjected to
but it is necessary. So I looked for the child's father whom I couldn't
find. Then I found his mother. I told her that the child's cardiac arrest
was due to bleeding in his throat; we don't know the cause of this bleeding
and fear that his brain is dead. So how do you think she responded? Did she
cry? Did she blame me? No, nothing of the sort. Instead, she said
"Alhamdulillah" (All Praise is due to ALLAH) and left me.

After 10 days, the child started moving. We thanked ALLAH and were happy
that his brain condition was reasonable. After 12 days, the heart stopped
again because of the same bleeding. We performed another cardiac massage for
45 minutes but this time his heart didn't respond. I told his mother that
there was no hope. So she said: "Alhamdulillah. O ALLAH, if there is good in
his recovery, then cure him, O my Lord."

With the grace of ALLAH, his heart started functioning again. He suffered
six similar cardiac arrests till a trachea specialist was able to stop the
bleeding and the heart started working properly. Now, three and a half
months had passed and the child was recovering but did not move. Then just
as he started moving, he was afflicted with a very large and strange
pus-filled abscess in his head, the likes of which I had never seen. I
informed his mother of the serious development. She said "Alhamdulillah" and
left me.

We immediately turned him over to the surgical unit that deals with the
brain and nervous system and they took over his treatment. Three weeks
later, the boy recovered from this abscess but was still not moving. Two
weeks pass and he suffers from a strange blood poisoning and his temperature
reaches 41.2°C (106°F). I again informed his mother of the serious
development and she said with patience and certainty: "Alhamdulillah. O
ALLAH, if there is good in his recovery, then cure him."

After seeing his mother who was with her child at Bed#5, I went to see
another child at Bed#6. I found that child's mother crying and screaming,
"Doctor! Doctor! Do something! The boy's temperature reached 37.6°C
(99.68°F)! He's going to die! He's going to die!" I said with surprise,
"Look at the mother of that child in Bed#5. Her child's fever is over 41°C
(106°F), yet she is patient and praises ALLAH." So she replied: "That woman
isn't conscious and has no senses". At that point, I remembered the great
Hadith of the Prophet (Sallallaahu Alaihi Wa Sallam): "Blessed are the
strangers." Just two words. but indeed two words that shake a nation! In 23
years of hospital service, I have never seen the likes of this patient
sister.

We continued to care for him. Now, six and a half months have passed and the
boy finally came out of the recovery unit - not talking, not seeing, not
hearing, not moving, not smiling, and with an open chest in which you can
see his beating heart. The mother changed the dressing regularly and
remained patient and hopeful. Do you know what happened after that? Before I
inform you, what do you think are the prospects of a child who has passed
through all these dangers, agonies, and diseases? And what do you expect
this patient mother to do whose child is at the brink of the grave and who
is unable to do anything except supplicate and beseech ALLAH? Do you know
what happened two and a half months later? The boy was completely cured by
the mercy of ALLAH and as a reward for this pious mother. He now races his
mother with his feet as if nothing happened and he became sound and healthy
as he was before.

The story doesn't end here. This is not what moved me and brought tears to
my eyes. What filled my eyes with tears is what follows:

One and a half years after the child left the hospital, one of the brothers
from the Operations Unit informed me that a man, his wife and two children
wanted to see me. I asked who they were and he replied that he didn't know
them. So I went to see them, and I found the parents of the same child whom
I operated upon. He was now five years old and like a flower in good health
- as if nothing happened to him. With them also was a four-month old
newborn. I welcomed them kindly and then jokingly asked the father whether
the newborn was the 13th or 14th child. He looked at me with an astonishing
smile as if he pitied me. He then said, "This is the second child, and the
child upon whom you operated is our first born, bestowed upon us after 17
years of infertility. And after being granted that child, he was afflicted
with the conditions that you've seen."

At hearing this, I couldn't control myself and my eyes filled with tears. I
then involuntarily grabbed the man by the arm, and pulling him to my room,
asked him about his wife: "Who is this wife of yours who after 17 years of
infertility has this much patience with all the fatal conditions that
afflict her first born?! Her heart cannot be barren! It must be fertile with
Imaan!"Do you know what he said? Listen carefully my dear brothers and
sisters. He said, "I was married to this woman for 19 years and for all
these years she has never missed the [late] night prayers except due to an
authorized excuse. I have never witnessed her backbiting, gossiping, or
lying. Whenever I leave home or return, she opens the door, supplicates for
me, and receives me hospitably. And in everything she does, she demonstrates
the utmost love, care, courtesy, and compassion." The man completed by
saying, "Indeed, doctor, because of all the noble manners and affection with
which she treats me, I'm shy to lift up my eyes and look at her. So I said
to him: "And the likes of her truly deserve that from you."

The End.

ALLAH says: And We will surely test you with something of fear and hunger
and a loss of wealth and lives and fruits, but give good tidings to the
patient; Who, when calamity strikes them, say, "Indeed we belong to ALLAH,
and indeed to HIM we will return." Those are the ones upon whom are
blessings from their Lord and mercy. And it is those who are the [rightly]
guided. (Surah Al-Baqarah 155-157)
 
Assalamu Alaikum
Salim


Umm Salamah (the wife of the Prophet) said: I heard the Messenger of ALLAH
(Sallallaahu Alaihi Wa Sallam) saying: "There is no Muslim who is stricken
by a calamity and says what ALLAH has commanded him - 'Indeed we belong to
ALLAH, and indeed to Him we will return; O ALLAH, reward me for my
affliction and compensate me with that which is better' - except that ALLAH
will grant him something better in exchange." When Abu Salamah [her former
husband] passed away, I said to myself: "What Muslim is better than Abu
Salamah?" I then said the words, and ALLAH gave me the Messenger of ALLAH
(Sallallaahu Alaihi Wa Sallam) in exchange. (Sahih Muslim Sharief)

-

~The only lasting beauty is the beauty of the heart

Tuesday, August 7, 2012

Why I choose Team Anna By Yogendra Yadav - The Indian Express

http://www.indianexpress.com/news/why-i-choose-team-anna/984727/0

The Indian Express

Why I choose Team Anna

YOGENDRA YADAV : Tue Aug 07 2012,
 
In choice between two less than pure sides, I prefer protesters’ infirmities to rulers’ intransigence

Feel disappointed with your decision to join this movement which has mediocrity and righteousness at its core...” This was an SMS from an old friend whose opinion matters to me. The context was the “Anna movement” and its decision to “embrace politics”. I was one of the signatories to the statement that called upon the fasting leaders to give up on their expectations from the political establishment and instead work towards creating an alternative political force, not necessarily a political party. Hence the message.

I could have ducked it, and pointed out that at the time of writing this I have not “joined” Team Anna. Those of us who signed the statement requesting Anna and his associates to call off the fast did so precisely because we were outsiders. I spoke from the podium as a friend and well-wisher, but not as a member. I could have also pointed out that every time I spoke from the stage, at Ramlila Maidan in August and December last year and at Jantar Mantar, I underlined a friendly disagreement with the movement. Yet the fact remained that I did extend moral support to the movement. This is what she questioned and I could not duck behind a formality.

I could have simply overlooked the message, as one odd response among many. Of the many responses that I have received in the last few days, the dominant voice has been positive, if not enthusiastic. I dare not speak of the aam aadmi, but the subset that I get to hear in my everyday life — ordinary TV viewers, middle class persons with casual interest in politics, lower middle class men who engaged me at Jantar Mantar and on the streets and ordinary activists in the movement circles who cared to call — had on balance supported this move. They had questions about its success but not about its rationale.

At the same time, the more intellectual, discerning and politically more astute responses have been more critical. Many of the finer minds and committed spirits have cautioned me against extending support to the movement. They may be in a minority. But this small voice is often the shell that protects one’s conscience. This SMS lay in that domain where brute majority must not prevail.

I could have, of course, disagreed with my friend. The Anna movement may have been anything, but mediocre it is not. The group of young activists involved in this movement has been amazingly innovative in its approach and strategy. They dared to make established political wisdom stand on its head. And the meticulous planning that went into the movement is anything but mediocre. Or, I could have retorted by asking how could she complain about the “righteousness” of a bunch of activists on the street in the face of shameless wrongdoings by those who wield unlimited and unaccountable power. How could we notice imagination deficits of the protesters, when compared to the heaps of lies that the government has dished out to protect its ministers and allies?

At least, the protesters have learnt a thing or two over the last one year. They have tried to distance themselves from blatant anti-politics and institution-bashing and from the ideological stream represented by Ramdev. The political establishment, on the other hand, is as coarse and smug, if not more, as it was last year.

That may have been a smart response but not fully honest. Faced with a real-life choice between two less than pure sides, one cannot but prefer the infirmities of the protesters to the insensitivity and intransigence of the rulers. Yet that does not justify the failures of Team Anna. Over the last 16 months, I have, more than once, felt uneasy about the stridency and hyperbole deployed from the podium. I wished Team Anna were more attentive to the constructive criticism and alternative proposals offered by their erstwhile colleagues in the NCPRI. I felt, and said so from the podium in Ramlila Maidan, that politicians’ corruption must not be used to cover our own. And yes, I could not disagree with her: monotonous righteousness that refused to look within often made me cringe.

I wanted to tell her something else. Anna movement was not my first real-life encounter with social and political movements. Over the last three decades, I have worked closely with a number of non-party political formations and non-mainstream parties. I have sat through a number of painful discussions and negotiations about transiting from “non-political” to “political”. And I know how lack of viability and visibility has finished some of the best political alternatives of our times before they could take off.

I wanted to tell her about my political guru, Kishen Pattnayak. For a full-time politician and former member of Lok Sabha, he was unbelievably self-effacing; you felt embarrassed talking about him in his presence. He did not draw any attention to himself; the media paid virtually no attention to him. He was as close to a fusion of morality and politics as I have seen in my life. He did not compromise on his principles, but he kept losing colleagues and followers to mainstream parties. He was the opposite of mediocrity: I think of him as one of the original minds of our time. His own followers did not quite understand him and the academia did not glance at someone who did not write in English. He was not frustrated or dejected. But the kind of alternative politics he spent his life building never ever took off.

I know what I do not wish to say to her. I am not saying that politics is not for the intelligent or the thin-skinned. I am not saying that palitiks mein sab chalta hai. I guess I wish to draw her attention to a deeper paradox of modern politics: politics opens at once the possibility of ethics in public life and also becomes the source of its routine negation. 

In our times, the pursuit of goodness draws you to politics, at the same time immersion in politics has a built-in drag away from goodness. For those who keep their eyes, ears and soul open, political choices are always very delicate, very complex, very painful.
I could not have said all this in an SMS. So I wrote this article.

The writer is senior fellow, Centre for the Study of Developing Societies, Delhi.
express@expressindia.com